Posts
Creative Problem Solving for Managers: Why Your MBA Didn't Teach You the Good Stuff
Related Reading:
The bloke sitting across from me in the Qantas Club last month was complaining about his "useless" team to anyone who'd listen. Classic middle manager. Probably earned his stripes climbing the corporate ladder with spreadsheets and PowerPoints. But when I asked him about the last time he'd actually created a solution rather than just implemented someone else's, he went quiet.
That's the problem with management training today. We teach people to manage processes, not to think creatively about problems.
The MBA Trap: Why Traditional Training Fails
Here's something that'll ruffle feathers: most management programs are actively killing creativity in the workplace. They're teaching linear thinking in a non-linear world. I've seen too many bright minds get channelled into "best practice" thinking that's really just yesterday's solutions dressed up as innovation.
The creative problem solving approach that actually works isn't found in any textbook I've read. It comes from understanding that problems are messy, human, and rarely fit into neat categories.
Take Toyota's approach to problem-solving. They don't just fix things - they redesign their entire thinking process around continuous improvement. That's not managing; that's creating. Big difference.
What Jazz Musicians Know That Managers Don't
I was watching a jazz quartet in Melbourne last year, and it hit me: these musicians were doing advanced creative problem solving in real-time. One player would throw in a unexpected chord change, and the others would instantly adapt, building something new and beautiful from what could have been a mistake.
That's exactly what managers need to learn.
Traditional problem-solving follows a script. Identify problem, analyse causes, implement solution, measure results. Boring. Predictable. Often wrong.
Creative problem-solving is more like jazz improvisation:
- Start with a structure but be ready to abandon it
- Listen to what's actually happening, not what you think should be happening
- Build on unexpected inputs from your team
- Make mistakes part of the creative process
The Three Things Business Schools Won't Tell You
First: The best solutions usually come from people who aren't supposed to have the answers. I once saw a receptionist solve a customer retention problem that had stumped the entire marketing department for months. She noticed patterns in the complaints that the data analysts had missed.
Second: Most "problems" aren't actually problems - they're symptoms. When productivity drops, managers typically blame processes or people. Creative managers ask different questions. What changed in the work environment? What pressures are people facing that they're not talking about?
Third: The fastest path to a solution is often the most indirect one. I learned this from a carpenter who taught me that sometimes you need to cut away from your target to get the angle right. Business problems work the same way.
Why Your Team Isn't Creative (Hint: It's Not Their Fault)
About 73% of employees say they have good ideas that never get heard. That's not a creativity problem - that's a management problem.
Most managers create environments that punish creative thinking without realising it. They ask for "innovative solutions" but then shoot down anything that doesn't fit existing budgets or timelines. They want "out-of-the-box thinking" but panic when someone actually suggests something outside the box.
Real creative problem-solving requires psychological safety. People need to know they can suggest something stupid without career consequences. They need time to think, not just react. And they need to see that creative solutions actually get implemented, not just praised and then buried.
The best managers I know create what I call "permission to be ridiculous." They actively encourage wild ideas in the brainstorming phase, knowing that great solutions often start as terrible suggestions that get refined.
The Nintendo Approach to Management Innovation
Nintendo has this brilliant habit of solving problems by changing the rules of the game entirely. When everyone else was competing on graphics processing power, they created the Wii and focused on motion controls. Instead of trying to beat Sony and Microsoft at their own game, they invented a completely different game.
That's advanced creative problem-solving.
Most managers try to solve problems within existing constraints. Creative managers question the constraints themselves. Why does this process take three weeks? Because it always has? That's not a reason, that's an excuse.
I remember working with a logistics company that was struggling with delivery delays. Traditional analysis focused on route optimisation and driver performance. But the real breakthrough came when someone asked: "Why are we promising same-day delivery in the first place?" Turned out customers cared more about accurate arrival windows than speed. Problem solved by reframing the entire question.
Building Creative Problem-Solving Muscle
Like any skill, creative problem-solving gets better with practice. But most managers practice the wrong things. They practice making decisions faster, not making better decisions.
Here's what actually works:
Start with assumption-hunting. Every problem comes loaded with assumptions about what's possible, what's allowed, what's been tried before. Write them down. Then deliberately challenge each one.
Use the "What if?" game religiously. What if budget wasn't a constraint? What if we had unlimited time? What if we were starting from scratch? These aren't practical questions - they're creative questions that open up new thinking.
Steal ideas from completely unrelated industries. How does McDonald's handle peak demand? How do emergency rooms prioritise urgent cases? How do film directors manage creative teams under pressure? There's gold in those cross-industry insights.
The Permission Problem
The biggest barrier to creative problem-solving isn't lack of ideas - it's lack of permission to implement them. Too many good solutions die in committee or get watered down until they're ineffective.
Smart managers solve this by changing how they frame problems. Instead of saying "We need to cut costs by 10%," they say "We need to deliver the same value with fewer resources." Different framing, different solutions.
Instead of "How do we reduce customer complaints?" try "How do we create customers who love telling their friends about us?" Suddenly you're not just fixing problems - you're creating opportunities.
The most successful managers I know have learned to ask better questions, not just find faster answers. They've figured out that creative problem-solving isn't a skill you add to your toolkit - it's a complete rewiring of how you approach management challenges.
And honestly? Once you start thinking this way, going back to traditional problem-solving feels like trying to paint with a broken brush. Possible, but why would you want to?
The companies that figure this out first will leave everyone else wondering what happened. The managers who don't will keep complaining about their "useless" teams while the real problem stares back at them from the bathroom mirror.