Blog

Creative Problem Solving: Why Your Team's Best Ideas Come from the Strangest Places

The other day I walked into a client meeting in Brisbane and found their entire management team arguing about a photocopier. Not just any photocopier argument, mind you – they'd been stuck on this "crisis" for three weeks. The machine kept jamming, staff were frustrated, and productivity was supposedly tanking.

Twenty minutes later, after watching grown professionals debate toner cartridge brands with the intensity of wine critics, I asked one question: "What if we just moved everyone's desks closer to the other photocopier?"

Silence. Then someone muttered, "We have another photocopier?"

That's creative problem solving in a nutshell, folks. Not some mystical business buzzword that requires expensive consultants (present company excluded), but the art of looking sideways when everyone else is staring straight ahead.

The Restaurant Test

I've got a theory about creative problem solving that I call the Restaurant Test. Picture this: you're running a busy café in Melbourne, and customers keep complaining about long wait times. The obvious solution? Hire more staff, speed up the kitchen, install those buzzing pager things that make everyone look like they're in witness protection.

But here's what one clever café owner did instead – she put magazines and newspapers near the entrance. Suddenly, perceived wait times dropped by 40%. People weren't waiting less; they were just less aware of waiting.

That's creative thinking. That's looking at the problem from the customer's emotional experience rather than just operational efficiency. It's brilliant because it's simple, and it's simple because someone dared to ask, "What if the problem isn't actually the problem?"

Most businesses approach creative problem solving like they're following a recipe. Step one: identify problem. Step two: brainstorm solutions. Step three: implement the most logical option. Step four: wonder why nothing changed.

Wrong. Completely wrong.

Creative problem solving starts with questioning whether you've even identified the right problem. It's uncomfortable territory for most managers because it means admitting that maybe, just maybe, you've been barking up the wrong tree for months.

The Curse of Obvious Solutions

I was working with a manufacturing company in Perth last year. Their "problem" was employee turnover – people kept leaving after six months. Management was convinced they needed better onboarding programs, more competitive salaries, maybe some team-building exercises involving trust falls and awkward rope courses.

Three conversations with departing employees later, we discovered the real issue: the car park. The bloody car park.

New employees were getting the furthest parking spots, which meant a five-minute walk in Perth summer heat, arriving at work already sweaty and frustrated. Long-term employees had claimed the shaded spots near the building like territorial animals. Nobody talked about it because, well, it's just parking, right?

Cost to fix: $200 for new signage rotating parking privileges monthly. Employee retention improvement: 78%. Management's face when they realised: priceless.

Breaking the Meeting Trap

Here's where most creative problem solving dies a slow, painful death – in meetings. You know the ones. Fifteen people around a table, someone with a whiteboard marker thinking they're Steve Jobs, and ideas flowing like molasses in winter.

"Let's think outside the box!" they cry, while sitting in the most box-like environment possible.

Real creative problem solving happens in strange places. In the shower. During lunch walks. While stuck in traffic cursing the M1. It happens when your brain isn't trying to perform for an audience.

The best strategic thinking and analytical training I've ever seen happened accidentally. A client's air conditioning broke during a workshop, so we moved outside under some trees. Something about being away from the corporate environment completely shifted how people thought about their challenges.

They solved a six-month inventory problem in forty minutes. Under a jacaranda tree. With magpies making a racket overhead.

The Sports Analogy That Actually Works

Bear with me here – I know business people love their sports analogies, and most of them are rubbish. But rugby league taught me something valuable about creative problem solving.

Watch a great halfback like Johnathan Thurston (back when he was playing). He's not just executing plays from a coaching manual. He's reading the defence, spotting the gaps that aren't supposed to be there, and improvising solutions in real time.

Business problems are the same. You can't solve them by running the same plays everyone else runs. You need to read the field differently.

I watched a small logistics company in Townsville completely revolutionise their delivery system by studying how pizza shops operate. Not their competitors – pizza shops. They realised that pizza delivery drivers had solved the "multiple stops, time-sensitive cargo" problem decades ago.

Result? They started clustering deliveries by temperature requirements instead of geographical zones. Crazy? Maybe. Effective? Their fuel costs dropped 23% and customer satisfaction went through the roof.

The Obvious Thing Everyone Misses

Want to know the biggest barrier to creative problem solving in Australian businesses? It's not lack of creativity or resources or time. It's the desperate need to look professional.

I've seen managers reject brilliant solutions because they seemed "too simple" or "not sophisticated enough." As if complexity equals quality. As if spending six months developing a solution is inherently better than finding one that works immediately.

There's this weird corporate theatre where everyone pretends that good solutions must be complicated, involve multiple stakeholders, and require expensive software. Nonsense.

Some of the best problem solving I've witnessed involved:

A receptionist who moved the coffee machine to reduce morning bottlenecks
An accountant who colour-coded invoices and eliminated 90% of payment delays
A warehouse manager who played classical music and reduced workplace injuries by 15%

None of these required consultants, committees, or change management processes. They just required someone to pay attention and try something different.

When Everything Else Fails

Sometimes creative problem solving means admitting you're solving the wrong problem entirely. Sometimes it means throwing out months of work and starting fresh. Sometimes it means the solution is so obvious you feel stupid for missing it.

I remember working with a tech startup that was haemorrhaging money on customer acquisition. They'd tried everything – Facebook ads, Google campaigns, influencer partnerships, even those annoying LinkedIn messages that make you question humanity.

Turns out their best customers were finding them through word-of-mouth recommendations. Always had been. So instead of spending thousands on advertising, they started sending handwritten thank-you notes to existing customers.

Customer referrals tripled within two months.

The solution wasn't creative marketing – it was creative gratitude.

The Uncomfortable Truth

Here's what nobody wants to hear about creative problem solving: most problems in Australian businesses aren't actually that complex. They just feel complex because we've made them complex.

We've layered processes on top of procedures on top of policies until simple issues become elaborate production numbers. We've convinced ourselves that sustainable solutions require months of planning when sometimes they just require someone to move the bloody photocopier.

Creative problem solving isn't about generating hundreds of wild ideas and hoping one sticks. It's about asking better questions, challenging assumptions, and having the courage to try simple solutions to complex-seeming problems.

And if that doesn't work? Well, there's always the jacaranda tree option.

The author runs business improvement workshops across Australia and has never met a problem that couldn't be improved by asking "What if we tried the opposite?" at least once.